Growing Rewards Program membership with coupon users

I recently spoke with one of my merchant coupon program client centers to get an update on their program's performance. They reported 700 merchant coupon users from the first 60 days of their coupon program and are tracking to hit 1000+ in the remaining months.

I knew from previous conversations that the center had a Rewards Program, so I asked if they were "auto enrolling" (my term) the 700 new visitors into their rewards program. They were not doing this and the manager thought they should start right away.


By "auto enrolling" I mean converting each coupon visitor into a new Rewards Program member by simply informing the coupon user that they are receiving the coupon's Free Game on a Rewards Card for instant use, and that their shoe rental, snacks and arcade purchases will earn them rewards immediately.

My logic is that the coupon users are approaching the counter with a coupon whose back form is filled out (or they will be asked to complete it) and are already prepared to share their contact info - a great time to make them a Rewards Program member.

The manager and I brainstormed a bit more and I suggested that each Birthday Party customer be automatically enrolled too. Turns out the center does a weekly Thank You mailing on Mondays to the weekend's party customers, and they now plan to insert a reward card loaded with points from the birthday sale into the mailings.


I have not (yet) worked in a center, but spent years in retail (auto) and know the challenges of balancing the serving of impatient customers along with trying to perform marketing functions like data entry and surveys. I read a report that said reward/loyalty programs boost the visit rate by 67%, so it seems worth the effort in order to bump a "3 visits a year" customer to 5 visits.


What are your experiences or thoughts on "auto enrolling" customer groups like coupon users and birthday party purchasers into Reward / Loyalty Programs?